Beyond the Maelstrom: Chaotic Behaviour is matter of Perspective

Beyond the Maelstrom: Chaotic Behaviour is matter of Perspective

I created the painting below almost two years ago to reflect the pain, frustration and disconnection I felt as an Agile consultant when working with a large organization. At the time I thought of Agile as a coherent system of energy – waves of light – illustrated by the yellow lines in the top left. Along with other coaches, we thought the organization was chaotic or complex as defined by the Cynefin framework. The organization is illustrated by blue structure. The severe difficulty we had working with it is expressed as a swirling mess of green. In hindsight it is clear to me that the mess of interactions was the result of the incompatible culture and thought systems between the coaches and the client organization. I suspect the client may have had the opposite perception: that they had a coherent and understandable structure while we Agile coaches seemed chaotic. Future success relies on understanding these differences in perspective due to culture and other dimensions. To help others avoid pain and waste, I wrote An Agile Adoption and Transformation Survival Guide: Working with Organizational Culture Consider reading it to learn from my failures and to avoid creating your own. This painting was one of the candidates for the cover... Continue reading »
Visual Summary of Agile Adoption and Transformation Survival Guide

Visual Summary of Agile Adoption and Transformation Survival Guide

After providing my 13th verbal summary of my session at Agile 2012, I realized that I did not have an infographic summarizing the session and book – An Agile Adoption and Transformation Survival Guide. So here they are. Agile Failure & Culture Agile Differs from Most Company Cultures   Adoption –> Doing Agile; Transformation –>Being Agile Agile Adoption <—->  Transformation There are a range of approaches – some are more appropriate for adoption vs. transformation.  ... Continue reading »
Agile Failure and Culture – Agile 2012 Workshop Results

Agile Failure and Culture – Agile 2012 Workshop Results

What follows are the workshop results from Agile 2012 Session “An Agile Adoption and Transformation Survival Guide”. Book, slides, and video explaining the session. The results are based on 120 people in the interactive section (there were another 60+ observers I was unable to involve). Confirmed Insights Failure rates are high. Success reports are 2.8 average out of 5. Control culture is dominant in the majority of companies. Agile culture is primarily about collaboration culture. Cultivation and Competence cultures and are secondary. Lot’s of companies are “doing Agile” practices, and not “being Agile” (mindset) Agile Failure rates are high As can be seen from the photo on the right, people have reported different levels of success with Agile. 5 means always successful and 0 means never successful. The average of the respondents is 2.8 out of 5. This is a success rate of a little less than 60%. Ouch! Reasons for Agile Failure The photo below shows the reasons participants encountered Agile Failure. Notice that the most common item mentioned was management understanding and support. Control culture is dominant in the majority of companies As we can see here, approximately 77 out of 108 participants indicated that their dominant organizational culture is Control using the Schneider model. This is a little higher than 70%. And this is at an Agile conference! Agile is about Collaboration culture In the workshop, participants were asked to associate Agile values and principles with the cultures of the Schneider culture model. All twelve tables agreed that the dominant culture expressed by Agile is about Collaboration. But what of Agile’s secondary culture? Three groups identified Cultivation... Continue reading »
Book – An Agile Adoption and Transformation Survival Guide: Working with Organizational Culture

Book – An Agile Adoption and Transformation Survival Guide: Working with Organizational Culture

I am very excited that I just published my free book – An Agile Adoption and Transformation Survival Guide: Working with Organizational Culture on InfoQ. Agile change agents will find it valuable in helping companies succeed with Agile and avoiding failure. About the Book Struggling with Agile? Frustrated that people don’t really get it? Tired of fighting with organizational bureaucracy? Wondering how you could have been more successful? If so, then this book is for you! The book provides a set of essential thinking tools for understanding Agile adoption and transformation: how they differ and what you need to know to know to avoid being another statistic in the widespread adoption failure. In particular, you will learn how to use culture to work more effectively with your organization. It is called a survival guide since so many people have found the concepts to be invaluable in understanding their experiences when working with Agile. This book includes: Identification of causes of the widespread Agile adoption failure A model for understanding Agile, Kanban, and Software Craftsmanship culture An outline of key adoption and transformation approaches A framework to help guide when to use these these approaches with your organization Real-life case studies of what has worked and what hasn’t Electronic Version is Free You can get a PDF or ePub version of the book for free on InfoQ. Why free? My primary goal is to change the world of work, and by making it free I can best achieve this goal. Of course, I would be really happy if you bought multiple copies of the print edition to give to your friends and... Continue reading »

What’s the first Decision? Implementing Kanban vs Scrum

Guest post by Michael DePaoli If your development team or manufacturing team is considering moving to using Kanban vs. Agile Scrum, one of the biggest decisions is choosing the right agile development methods for the job. Let’s discuss the realities of implementing Kanban and some of the fundamentals that hold back both Kanban and Scrum implementations. On paper, Kanban is certainly easier to kick-start from a change management perspective because you can leave current roles and processes largely intact; you just need to get commitment from the business to adhere to three basic principles: Provide a high degree of visibility/transparency of the state of all work queued and in progress Establish and respect WIP(work in progress) limits in the value flow Commit to execution in a ‘pull-based’ manner from the prioritized work queue Yeah, just get commitment and practice of these three things… Much easier said than done in my experience because they are frequently outside the circle of influence of those driving the change to implementing Kanban! Usually it isn’t that the agile software teams are unable to execute under Scrum; the fundamental issue is that the business isn’t willing to accept a “pull-based” execution model (required for Kanban and Scrum). Businesses continue to make irresponsible commitments to customers and investors. This only perpetuates crystal-ball thinking, fixed-date, fixed-scope and fixed-cost projects. It’s the classic sales-driven model we see all too often where the sales arm doesn’t respect the capability of its product development group to produce predictable value for the customer in a timely manner, and with an agreed-upon level of quality. After all, quality is a business decision. This irresponsible action ends up causing organizations to be unpredictable in their delivery, have... Continue reading »

Agile Culture and Adoption Survival Guide – Full Video!

I am very grateful to New England Agile (and Ron Verge in particular) for videotaping my presentation. For those of you who haven’t heard me speak about culture and adoption, I believe this is a crucial message for anyone acting as an Agile change agent. Enjoy. Agile Culture and Adoption Survival Guide from Agile New England on Vimeo. P.S. I am actively working on an eBook for those who prefer print. Drop me an email if you want to help review it before it comes out. P.P.S Slides are... Continue reading »
Agile Failure and Corporate Culture

Agile Failure and Corporate Culture

Last week I presented Agile Culture and Adoption Survival Guide at Agile New England. My message was around needing to understand corporate culture before undertaking Agile adoption or Agile transformation. The message resonated really strongly with participant and I received many personal thanks from people afterwards. The purpose of this post is to share additional data from that session. Agile Failure I did a hand vote to see how much failure people had seen with Agile adoption they were involved in. See photo on the right: most of the group rated their experiences with Agile success at 3 out of 5. The results were pretty much consistent with the other times I have  run this: about 50% failure. I guess we can call this one – Agile is heading for the trough of disillusionment. But I haven’t given up – it’s time to up our game and turn this around. Culture at Participant Companies  Participants were worked in small groups to discuss what was the dominant culture at their company using the Schneider Model.  The photo below shows a histogram of the dominant culture. The peak is 30 participants identifying a control culture. It is interesting to note the relatively high 16 for Competence culture (vs. previous workshops) that represents the high density of hard-core engineering companies in the Boston area. Closing Thoughts Maybe the 50% failure is because 50% of the companies are control culture. Probably not entirely true, but this may be a helpful meme that allows us to change our approaches and behaviours to... Continue reading »
Page 2 of 612345...Last »